Movies Like Once Upon a Time in Amityville (2024)

Name: Once Upon a Time in Amityville
Director: Mark Polonia
Genre: Horror, Thriller, Western
Released: 2024

Discover horror films similar to Once Upon a Time in Amityville (2024). These recommendations are ranked by similarity across plot, mood, director style, cast, and more.

Where to watch Once Upon a Time in Amityville →

Dead Birds(2004)

46% match

Horror, Thriller, Western · 91 min · Dir. Alex Turner

Western

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Blood River(2009)

44% match

Horror, Thriller, Western · 104 min · Dir. Adam Mason

Western

Where to watch Similar →Compare

The Burrowers(2008)

44% match

Horror, Thriller, Western · 96 min · Dir. J.T. Petty

Western

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Malicious(2018)

44% match

Horror, Thriller · 90 min · Dir. Michael Winnick

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Our Evil(2017)

43% match

Drama, Horror, Thriller · 92 min · Dir. Samuel Galli

Prime Plex

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Darling(2015)

43% match

Horror, Thriller · 78 min · Dir. Mickey Keating

Prime Plex

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Incarnate(2016)

41% match

Horror, Thriller · 87 min · Dir. Brad Peyton

Where to watch Similar →Compare

Browse related lists

Best Horror Films of the 2020s Best Horror Films of 2024 Best Psychological Horror Films Best Psychological Thriller Horror Films Best Horror Films of All Time

Browse by mood

Slow-burn horror

We use analytics to understand how visitors discover horror films and improve recommendations. No data is sold or shared. You can change your mind anytime in your browser settings.

7 Psychological Horror Films Like Once Upon a Time in Amityville (2024) | Horrorsight